Jerome Bruner and William James Regarding Pragmatism ’ s Does Pragmatism
نویسنده
چکیده
As its most basic mission, pragmatism sets out to determine an idea’s merit by examining its practical consequences, rather than through purely abstract evaluation. As a result of this emphasis on an idea’s effectiveness, the complex ways in which pragmatists conceive of abstract notions such as truth and self-concept are often overlooked. Close examination of the works of two pragmatist thinkers, William James and Jerome Bruner, reveals a crucial debate regarding pragmatism’s goal. The gap between the pragmatisms of James and Bruner can best be exposed by looking at their attitudes toward pluralism. For Bruner, pluralism is the goal of pragmatism from the outset of inquiry; in this model, pragmatism is used to mediate between multiple sets of beliefs. For James, however, a pragmatist must be open-minded, in that pragmatism is committed to examining all new ideas, but the goal of inquiry is to support one belief rather than many. The relationship of pluralism to pragmatism has crucial implications for the way in which the two thinkers conceive of the human capacity for self-knowledge.
منابع مشابه
Five Answers on Pragmatism
Prof. Haack answers a series of questions on pragmatism, beginning with the origins of this tradition in the work of Peirce and James, its evolution in the work of Dewey and Mead, and its influence beyond the United States in, for example, the Italian pragmatists and the radical British pragmatist F. C. S. Schiller. Classical pragmatism, she observes, is a rich and varied tradition from which t...
متن کاملWilliam James’s psychological pragmatism: habit, belief and purposive human behaviour
Modern institutional economists look to pragmatism for: (1) an evolutionary philosophy of knowledge; and (2) a foundation of a theory of human nature. These two elements are combined in William James, who was both a philosopher of pragmatism and a pioneering experimental psychologist. The author shows first how William James added psychological depth to the pragmatic tradition as it was left by...
متن کامل~ London and New York / 1 \ lb 1 PRAGMATISM AND ENVIRONMENTAL THOUGHT
"Pragmatism" here refers to a school of philosophical thought American pragmatism and not to that shortsighted, allegedly "practical-minded" attitude towards the world that is a major obstacle to environmentally responsible behavior in our time. 1 The insight behind "environmental pragmatism" is that American pragmatism is a philosophy of environments. Although the founders of pragmatism rarely...
متن کامل